• Front Page
    • Digital Education
    • Terry Freedman's Books Bulletin
  • RSS
  • Search
    • Welcome
    • The "About" Page
    • Testimonials
    • CV/Resumé
    • My Writing
    • Published articles
  • Corrections Policy
Menu

ICT & Computing in Education

Articles on education technology and related topics
  • Front Page
  • Newsletters
    • Digital Education
    • Terry Freedman's Books Bulletin
  • RSS
  • Search
  • Info
    • Welcome
    • The "About" Page
    • Testimonials
    • CV/Resumé
    • My Writing
    • Published articles
  • Corrections Policy
Big Data, by Terry Freedman

Big Data, by Terry Freedman

Data for its own sake is pointless

June 5, 2019

I noticed a few years ago at the Bett show that companies were going for data recording in a big way. For example, an online textbook system measures how much of a book a student has read, how long they spent on it, and probably what they were wearing at the time.

What's the point?

Data is only useful if it provides information, and especially information that would be hard to get in another way. In this case, I think the following:

  • Is it possible to game the system? If I thought I was being measured on how long I spend reading something, I'd be tempted to start the system up and then go out for a few hours!

  • Is the data correlated with other data? If I spend three hours reading something, compared with your 10 minutes, does that mean I find the subject matter difficult, I'm a slower reader, you're not interested, that I don't find the author's writing style very engaging, or what?

  • Is the data correlated with other data? For example, do students who spend longer on a text obtain better test results?

  • Is the system integrated with the school's management information system? I saw several products at the Bett show (2019) where the answer was "No", so you would end up having two logins, two sets of data, and a lot of work integrating the two.

  • What does it tell you anyway? When I'm reading, I stop every so often to think about what I'm reading, and the kind of things I think the author might cover. I've said more about my approach to reading in an article about reading efficiently. 

    Reader LM made a similar point when we were discussing some headphones that can measure the wearer's brainwaves to check if they're paying attention. Maybe they are making all sorts of connections in their minds, but the headphones would probably conclude that they were "merely" daydreaming.

  • How do such systems meet GDPR (or other privacy laws) requirements? You're supposed to gather and retain only data that is used for specific purposes, and for which people have given their consent. I'm no legal expert, but the concept of headphones that measure and store pupils’ brainwaves for no obvious reason or without their informed consent sounds like a nightmare to me.

  • Here's a radical suggestion, in case you're thinking of buying a system that measures brainwaves, time spent on a task, and similar personal data. Rather than be concerned with input, look at output. In other words, if a student can answer a question or do well on a test, that is the only thing you need to know about them. If someone doesn't do well, set a diagnostic test or even (outlandish suggestion coming up), talk to them. Indeed, talking to them will also prove useful when you wish to check whether they obtained the right answer for the right reason. See? I’ve just saved you a load of money!


This article first appeared in the Digital Education newsletter.

In Infographics, Leading & Managing Computing & ICT, News & views, Reflections Tags Bett, data, big data, pointless
← Is robotics a waste of time?Writing technology manuals for school: why, what and how →
Recent book reviews
The Learning Rainforest Great Teaching in Real Classrooms Great Teaching in Real Classrooms.jpg
Review: The Learning Rainforest: Great Teaching in Real Classrooms

This is a great book for dipping into in order to read about different teaching and assessment strategies, backed up by research.

Read more →
Outstanding Formative Assessment Culture and Practice.jpg
Review: Outstanding Formative Assessment: Culture and Practice

This book contains numerous assessment for learning techniques.

Read more →
New Media in the Classroom Rethinking Primary Literacy.jpg
Review: New Media in the Classroom: Rethinking Primary Literacy

This provides a great deal of information about the different aspects of "literacy” and how digital tools can be brought into the service of literacy in the primary school.

Read more →
Designing the internet of things.jpg
Review: Designing the internet of things

This book takes you through the process of designing connected devices from prototyping to launching.

Read more →
Uneducated.jpg
Quick look: (Un)educated: My Life as a Teacher, and Why You Should Never Become One

“Some of it is laugh-out loud funny, but some of it, about his reference being spiked, made me angry …”

Read more →
Hot TYpe.jpg
A Heads-up: Hot Type: The Magnificent Machine that Gave Birth to Mass Media and Drove Mark Twain Mad

This is about the invention of linotype, and its consequences.

Read more →
The new dark ages.jpg
Are we in, or entering, a post-literate society?

I know that there are people who think that Tik-Tok videos and other (very) short-form content is a kind of literacy that’s on a par with reading, but I have my doubts.

Read more →
amazing worlds.jpg
Review: Amazing Worlds

A very good showcase for what can be achieved from a partnership between imagination and AI.

Read more →
The Batsford Book of Chess for Children.jpg
Review: The Batsford Book of Chess for Children New Edition: Beginner’s chess for kids

This book doesn’t have any education technology, but I think the game of chess is a worthwhile activity for kids for developing strategic thinking skills.

Read more →
Flattening Classrooms, Engaging Minds.jpg
Review: Flattening Classrooms, Engaging Minds: Move to Global Collaboration One Step at a Time (Pearson Resources for 21st Century Learning)

The authors of this book, ran several projects which entailed collaboration between students in classrooms in different countries.

Read more →
Dig+Ed+Banner.jpg

Contact us

Privacy

Cookies

Terms and conditions

This website is powered by Squarespace

(c) Terry Freedman All Rights Reserved