­
Quick look: The Meritocracy Trap — ICT & Computing in Education
  • Front Page
  • Search
    • Digital Education
    • Terry Freedman's Books Bulletin
  • RSS
    • Welcome
    • The "About" Page
    • Testimonials
    • CV/Resumé
    • My Writing
    • Published articles
  • Corrections Policy
Menu

ICT & Computing in Education

Articles on education technology and related topics
  • Front Page
  • Search
  • Newsletters
    • Digital Education
    • Terry Freedman's Books Bulletin
  • RSS
  • Info
    • Welcome
    • The "About" Page
    • Testimonials
    • CV/Resumé
    • My Writing
    • Published articles
  • Corrections Policy
The Meritocracy Trap.jpg

Quick look: The Meritocracy Trap

December 11, 2019

Click the cover to see the book on Amazon (affiliate link)

I’ve just reviewed this book for a magazine called Teach Secondary. The author has an interesting thesis. We like to believe that meritocracy is a good thing, in that it rewards effort, and acts as a great leveller. In this scenario, it doesn’t matter how lowly the circumstances into which you are born, you can climb the ladder of success and get to the top.

Markovits argues that there is now what he calls ‘high-end inequality’: that is, inequality between the middle class and the upper class elite. Whereas absolute poverty still elicits sympathy (or ought to), few people are going to lose sleep over a middle class person having to work harder and longer to enjoy certain benefits.

When I reviewed the book for Teach Secondary, I was looking at it very broadly: it’s the sort of book that could be useful in several subjects. For example, Citizenship perhaps, Sociology definitely, Economics absolutely. But now I am reading it specifically with regard to the role played by technology, and I hope to revisit this book on the ICT & Computing in Education website having done so.

One thing that strikes me is the lengths to which parents will go to further the interests of their children, and I think this is where I might disagree with Markovits. First, unless I am very much mistaken, that attitude is not solely the province of middle class parents. Perhaps I am judging too much from my own experience (always a danger), but while my parents could not afford to pay for private tuition for me, they encouraged me to keep on in full-time education despite the financial hardships which that entailed. Secondly, why should the disparity between middle class and upper class bother anyone, if jobs in the upper echelons of society are open to all?

Now, you might argue that that’s the point: they are not open to all. It depends on who you know, most jobs are not advertised and so on. But that is the case in all levels of society, at least in Britain. Now, I might change my mind when I’ve read this book for a second time, but so far I remain unconvinced that meritocracy no longer works. I wonder if it’s like that old view of democracy: the worst of all systems apart from the alternatives?

Despite my reservations, I would like to recommend this book. It has a very different take on meritocracy, at least in the way it is working out in practice. Although it’s American, there is a postscript that deals specifically with the UK. And unlike a lot of academic books, it’s actually quite readable.

Update

Book review: The Meritocracy Trap

In Books in Brief, Bookshelf, Quick Looks, Reviews Tags Meritocracy, Markovits, inequality
← Ofsted: how is the new framework shaping up? UpdatedBett 2020 Dates for your diary →
Recent book reviews
Review: Social Media for Academics
Review: Social Media for Academics

This book is very readable, and if I sound surprised that is because it’s not always true of academics!

Read More →
Quick looks: VIBE Coding by Example
Quick looks: VIBE Coding by Example

For the time being, this book is free in Kindle format.

Read More →
Review: The Game Changers: How Playing Games Changed the World and Can Change You Too
Review: The Game Changers: How Playing Games Changed the World and Can Change You Too

Despite the relative paucity of immediately obvious National Curriculum links, teachers will find several of sections of this book to be highly engaging.

Read More →
Review: The Dictators: 64 Dictators, 64 Authors, 64 Warnings from History
Review: The Dictators: 64 Dictators, 64 Authors, 64 Warnings from History

In some respects one could view this book as a single warning repeated 64 times.

Read More →
Review: The Bookshop, The Draper, The Candlestick Maker: A History of the High Street 
Review: The Bookshop, The Draper, The Candlestick Maker: A History of the High Street 

Taking readers from the Middle Ages to (more or less) the present day, Gray charts how the places where we do our shopping and what we buy have changed over the centuries.

Read More →
Review: Extraordinary Learning For All
Review: Extraordinary Learning For All

As a source of potential ideas and inspiration, the book could be very useful indeed.

Read More →
Review: Bad Education: Why Our Universities Are Broken and How We Can Fix Them
Review: Bad Education: Why Our Universities Are Broken and How We Can Fix Them

One has the impression that the main role of the university these days is to maximise profit, while that of the majority of teaching staff is to ensure the ‘correct’ views are passed on to students. All the while, students’ main concern seems to be to seek protection from anything that might make them feel unsafe.

Read More →
Review: Next Practices - An Executive Guide for Education Decision Makers
Review: Next Practices - An Executive Guide for Education Decision Makers

Is a 2014 book on managing the computing provision in a school still worth buying?

Read More →
Still relevant (sadly): How to lie with statistics, by Darrell Huff
Still relevant (sadly): How to lie with statistics, by Darrell Huff

Although this book is over 60 years old, it is remarkably apposite for our times -- and especially in the fields of educational research and assessing pupils' understanding and progress.

Read More →
Quick looks: Bad Education: Why Our Universities Are Broken and How We Can Fix Them
Quick looks: Bad Education: Why Our Universities Are Broken and How We Can Fix Them

It was a great source of pride to me, getting hundreds of students through their A levels and encouraging them to go to university. But for some time I have asked myself a question: would I recommend this route now?

Read More →
Dig+Ed+Banner.jpg

Contact us

Privacy

Cookies

Terms and conditions

This website is powered by Squarespace

(c) Terry Freedman All Rights Reserved