­
Dystopian Visions: The Machine That Won the War (Revisited) — ICT & Computing in Education
  • Front Page
  • Search
    • Digital Education
    • Terry Freedman's Books Bulletin
  • RSS
    • Welcome
    • The "About" Page
    • Testimonials
    • CV/Resumé
    • My Writing
    • Published articles
  • Corrections Policy
Menu

ICT & Computing in Education

Articles on education technology and related topics
  • Front Page
  • Search
  • Newsletters
    • Digital Education
    • Terry Freedman's Books Bulletin
  • RSS
  • Info
    • Welcome
    • The "About" Page
    • Testimonials
    • CV/Resumé
    • My Writing
    • Published articles
  • Corrections Policy

Dystopian Visions, by Terry Freedman

Dystopian Visions: The Machine That Won the War (Revisited)

December 5, 2024

Given how worried some people are about our becoming too reliant on computers, an issue that is, perhaps, even more relevant today with the advent of very advanced artificial intelligence, it might be interesting to read and discuss this story by Isaac Asimov, published in 1961. It prompts us to ask: what really happens when a computer is invented that can make every decision in a war?

As well as discussing what happens in the story, it would be interesting I think to discuss whether this story could be written nowadays, or at least in the very near future. Would it be as convincing?

I’ll reveal the plot in a minute, but if you’d rather read the story first, you’ll find it in this book:

Click the image to see this book on Amazon (affiliate link)

Asimov conceived of an all-powerful computer called Multivac. In terms of what it can do, it’s not that far removed from our current and envisaged AI capacity. The situation is that Earth has just won the war against aliens, and the three people most closely involved with the decision-making each assumed that Multivac was responsible. However, it turns out that, one person didn’t trust the data he was supposed to put in, and someone else, independently, didn’t trust the data that came out. (He introduced what he called “the bugger factor”.)

The person responsible for decision-making on the battlefield didn’t trust it all, so he ignored it. The others ask him what he did then.

“Well, it’s time to be getting back perhaps but – I’ll tell you first. Why not? I did make use of a computer, Max, but an older one than Multivac, much older.”

He groped in his own pocket for cigarettes, and brought out a package along with a scattering of small change; old-fashioned coins dating to the first years before the metal shortage had brought into being a credit system tied to a computer-complex.

Swift smiled rather sheepishly. “I still need these to make money seem substantial to me. An old man finds it hard to abandon the habits of youth.” He put a cigarette between his lips and dropped the coins one by one back into his pocket.

He held the last coin between his fingers, staring absently at it. “Multivac is not the first computer, friends, nor the best-known, nor the one that can most efficiently lift the load of decision from the shoulders of the executive. A machine did win the war, John; at least a very simple computing device did; one that I used every time I had a particularly hard decision to make.”

With a faint smile of reminiscence, he flipped the coin he held. It glinted in the air as it spun and came down in Swift’s outstretched palm. His hand closed over it and brought it down on the back of his left hand. His right hand remained in place, hiding the coin. “Heads or tails, gentlemen?” said Swift.

I’ve always loved that ending! Heads or tails, gentlemen? Marvellous!

Interestingly enough, whenever I’ve had occasion to develop a spreadsheet, I’ve allowed for a certain degree of randomisation or user input — the bugger factor. The simple fact is, although I love spreadesheets and other apps that can automate decisions, there are some occasions when the user needs to exercise a bit of common sense. “Computer says ‘No’” is, to my mind, an indication of very poor programming.


This updated version first appeared in my Eclecticism newsletter, here. Go there if you'd like to leave a comment.

If you found this article interesting or useful (or both), why not subscribe to my free newsletter, Digital Education? It’s been going since the year 2000, and has slow news, informed views and honest reviews for Computing and ed tech teachers — and useful experience-based tips.

In Discussion topic, Dystopian Visions Tags Asimov, machine that won the war, Dystopian visions
← Dystopian Visions: A Sound of Thunder, by Ray Bradbury (updated)Dystopian Visions: Flowers for Algernon Revisited →
Recent book reviews
Review: Bad Education: Why Our Universities Are Broken and How We Can Fix Them
Review: Bad Education: Why Our Universities Are Broken and How We Can Fix Them

One has the impression that the main role of the university these days is to maximise profit, while that of the majority of teaching staff is to ensure the ‘correct’ views are passed on to students. All the while, students’ main concern seems to be to seek protection from anything that might make them feel unsafe.

Read More →
Review: Next Practices - An Executive Guide for Education Decision Makers
Review: Next Practices - An Executive Guide for Education Decision Makers

Is a 2014 book on managing the computing provision in a school still worth buying?

Read More →
Still relevant (sadly): How to lie with statistics, by Darrell Huff
Still relevant (sadly): How to lie with statistics, by Darrell Huff

Although this book is over 60 years old, it is remarkably apposite for our times -- and especially in the fields of educational research and assessing pupils' understanding and progress.

Read More →
Quick looks: Bad Education: Why Our Universities Are Broken and How We Can Fix Them
Quick looks: Bad Education: Why Our Universities Are Broken and How We Can Fix Them

It was a great source of pride to me, getting hundreds of students through their A levels and encouraging them to go to university. But for some time I have asked myself a question: would I recommend this route now?

Read More →
Review: The Bright Side: Why Optimists Have the Power to Change the World
Review: The Bright Side: Why Optimists Have the Power to Change the World

At first glance, you might take this to be one of those books full of affirmations and anecdotes designed to lift your mood.

Read More →
Review: Small Habits Create Big Change: Strategies to Avoid Burnout and Thrive in Your Education Career
Review: Small Habits Create Big Change: Strategies to Avoid Burnout and Thrive in Your Education Career

My review of this for Teach Secondary magazine has just come out. Here is the published version, followed by the copy I submitted, which is slightly longer because it has a little more detail.

Read More →
Review: Productive Failure: Unlocking Deeper Learning Through the Science of Failing
Review: Productive Failure: Unlocking Deeper Learning Through the Science of Failing

My review of this for Teach Secondary magazine has just come out. Here is the published version, followed by the copy I submitted, which is slightly longer because it is a little more detailed.

Read More →
Review: AI Snake Oil: AI Snake Oil: What Artificial Intelligence Can Do, What It Can’t, and How to Tell the Difference
Review: AI Snake Oil: AI Snake Oil: What Artificial Intelligence Can Do, What It Can’t, and How to Tell the Difference

My review of this for Teach Secondary magazine has just come out. Here is the published version, followed by the copy I submitted, which is slightly longer because it has a little more detail.

Read More →
When AI can write as well as this, I'll worry! Plus a prize competition.
When AI can write as well as this, I'll worry! Plus a prize competition.

To paraphrase what Arthur C Clarke said about teachers, any writer that can be replaced by a computer probably should be.

Read More →
Review: The Shortest History of Music -- two reviews in one!
Review: The Shortest History of Music -- two reviews in one!

The music programme of study requires students to possess an understanding of the music they perform and that which they listen to, as well as a grasp of music history, and an appreciation of different musical styles.

Read More →
Dig+Ed+Banner.jpg

Contact us

Privacy

Cookies

Terms and conditions

This website is powered by Squarespace

(c) Terry Freedman All Rights Reserved